Forum Members Rate MMJ Studio Albums - 2011

[APR]

Fun but so difficult.....

ISM - 9
Z -    7
AD -  6
C -    4
EU-   3
TFF -  1

CURRENTLY

It Still Moves     123.5
AD                    123
Z                       106.5
TFF                     77
Circuital              58.5
Evil Urges           49.5

[johnnYYac]

Oh! It Still Moves edges out At Dawn for the first time!  Such excitement!  What a match, ladies and gentlemen!  How will it end?

[mjk73]

AD   9
ISM   8
Z   6
TTF   5
C   1
Eu   1


AD   132
ISM   131.5
Z   112.5
TTF   82
C   59.5
Eu   50.5

[davymac]

Z-8
ISM-6
C-5
AD-5
TTF-4
EU-2

CURRENTLY


AD   137
ISM   137.5
Z   120.5
TTF   86
C   64.5
Eu   52.5

[ManNamedTruth]

Z - 8
AD - 6.5
ISM - 6.5
C - 5
TTF - 3
EU - 1

CURRENTLY

AD - 143.5
ISM - 144
Z - 128.5
TTF - 89
C - 69.5
EU - 53.5

[pawpaw]

ISM   7.5
TTF   7
C   5.5
AD   5
Z   4.5
EU   0.5

Current:

ISM   151.5
AD   148.5
Z   133
TTF   96
C   75
EU   54

[BigHerm]

ISM - 8
AD- 6.5
Z- 6.5
C - 5
TTF -3
EU - 1

Current:

ISM   159.5
AD   155
Z   139.5
TTF   99
C   80
EU 55

[BigHerm]

...

[Penny Lane]

Penny, I did not realize you were such a Circuital hater!

not a hater...i like it-- but we were asked to rank it next to the other albums!
it doesn't come close in comparison..

[Crispy]

Penny, I did not realize you were such a Circuital hater!

not a hater...i like it-- but we were asked to rank it next to the other albums!
it doesn't come close in comparison..

I hear you -- should have winked in my post -- just surprised to see it two clicks below EU. For me, Circuital's overall a better record, but of course, your opinion is yours. (CRAZY  ;) )

And ISM now has a clear lead over AD! I wonder if all of these numbers should be compiled by an independent auditing organization.

[jones]

ISM  7
Z  6.5
AD  6
TTF  5
C  4
EU  1.5


CURRENT:

ISM   166.5
AD   161
Z   146
TTF   104
C   84
EU 56.5

[kydiddle]

Agh! jones and I posted at the same time. I will add my total to his post.

ISM 8
AD 7
TTF 5
Z 5
C 3
EU 2

Current:
ISM   174.5
AD   168
Z   151
TTF   109
C   87
EU 58.5

OH MY GOD! Third modification...i can't flippin add...  ???

[jones]

Thanks, I was just about to do the same!

[ellisintransit]

Please don't interpret the low low score for TTF as an indictment.  When you love every single album by a band, it's hard to do something like this.  And yet.....

ISM  9.5
Z      7
AD   5.5
C     3.5
EU   2.5
TTF  2

Current:
ISM  184
AD    173.5
Z      158
TTF   111
C      90.5
EU    61

[diddy57]

Really tough assignment here, because all of the albums have their specific attributes. Call me a centrist.

Z       6
ISM   6
AD    5
C      5
EU    4
TF     4

[rincon]

ISM  8
AT  8
Z  6
TTF 4
EU 3
C 1

That is about right. Some room to play in the top 3, and change AT to AD, and it is my list.

[johnnYYac]

so far...

ISM  198
AD    186.5
Z      170
TTF   119
C      96.5
EU    68

I won't bother looking back to my contribution to this here effort, but the current totals seem about right to me, at this moment. 

[Ruckus]

ISM  8
AT  8
Z  6
TTF 4
EU 3
C 1

That is about right. Some room to play in the top 3, and change AT to AD, and it is my list.

Or you could submit your own.  Just sayin'

[rincon]

ISM  8
AT  8
Z  6
TTF 4
EU 3
C 1

That is about right. Some room to play in the top 3, and change AT to AD, and it is my list.

Or you could submit your own.  Just sayin'

If I am gonna plagerize, I will give credit where it is due. A point here or there between the top 3 in negligable at best. Just sayin.

[Roscog]

AD - 8
ISM -7
TTF -5
C -   5
Z  -  3 (like this album (songs) better in a live setting)
EU --2