My Morning Jacket (the album)

[Come Closer]

I know this is the letting songs breathe album, but I think some of the supporting cast could've been trimmed a bit. I would like Out of Range more if it was about 45 seconds shorter. Penny and Lucky could probably use a haircut too.

[C.S.]

It's really blowing my mind that there isn't more gushing over this one. 10/10 album of the year for me.

[GO4IT]

Loving the album more with each spin. Certainly a couple I could do without but I'm really loving Never in the Real World and In Color from the first listens. Others are growing on me.

Please, Lord, deliver us a beastly version of Never in the Real World in Chicago

Thank you, Lord

[RobRoy286]

It's really blowing my mind that there isn't more gushing over this one. 10/10 album of the year for me.

Oh I'm still gushing, don't worry

[Come Closer]

Not sure if you're talking about gushing here or gushing everywhere, but I really think it would've been better received if they trimmed it down. Not that I care about Pitchfork in the least, but I don't think it's a coincidence that they trashed Evil Urges and s/t and were favorable towards Circuital and The Waterfall. I don't think their albums should be more than 50 mins now that they're not doing the slowcore/post rock influenced thing and Jim isn't churning out songs like he was early on.

[MPP]

It's really blowing my mind that there isn't more gushing over this one. 10/10 album of the year for me.

Oh I'm still gushing, don't worry

It's been on repeat for the last three days. Musical crack. I loved WII when it released, still do, but it continues 2010-2015 with a few twists.  This is a brand new, thrilling landscape.

I'm only lukewarm on one song here, Lucky.  First half just sounds too pop formulaic and simplistic for me - for a Jacket song, to be clear.  Still fun, light years better than the typical formula, and no one adds that cool, keys/guitar laden outro to a song like they do. 

Penny is my choice for best song here, In Color a close second. That could change after more plays, considering I was negative on Love Love Love the first three plays, and now can't get it out of my head.  I get a strong Velvet Underground vibe in Penny,  and Bo's organ is straight outta 70's classic/Wakeman prog rock. Out of Range - love it.  I think Carpet Crawlers every time it starts.  Someone on this forum is going to get that reference. Lol

The range of song styles, done so well, is breathtaking.  Even a little Jazz! Patrick and Tom are amazingly accomplished at laying down so many diverse rhythms to build on. 

[parkervb]

correct me if I'm wrong, but we don't have live debuts of Devil, and the closing three tracks? I love those last 3 songs. Was Least Expected just debuted in Chicago?

[CountSA]

Least Expected was debuted in St. Louis.  Penny has been played 2 or 3 times.  Devil in the Details, Out of Range pt2, and Never Could Get Enough haven't been played yet.

correct me if I'm wrong, but we don't have live debuts of Devil, and the closing three tracks? I love those last 3 songs. Was Least Expected just debuted in Chicago?

[Nikkogino]

As much as I like Devil for what it is and the potential it could have live, would I prefer a 15 minute version of this song over, say, a Phone Went West, Dondante, Steam, or War Begun.  Hell no.

[parkervb]

Least Expected was debuted in St. Louis.  Penny has been played 2 or 3 times.  Devil in the Details, Out of Range pt2, and Never Could Get Enough haven't been played yet.

correct me if I'm wrong, but we don't have live debuts of Devil, and the closing three tracks? I love those last 3 songs. Was Least Expected just debuted in Chicago?

i hope Never Could Get Enough doesn't go the way of Only Memories...

[Lucius]

Are there any recordings of Only Memories out there where the crowd doesn't talk through it? Such a pretty song and I love the way it builds up live but I've never managed to find a taping where I'm not sitting there thinking "shut up shut up SHUT UP" about the crowd   

[RobRoy286]

Was reallyyy hoping to hear Out of Range in Chicago.

The songs I did hear were amazing. In Color is an instant classic.

[sillyboob]

Are there any recordings of Only Memories out there where the crowd doesn't talk through it? Such a pretty song and I love the way it builds up live but I've never managed to find a taping where I'm not sitting there thinking "shut up shut up SHUT UP" about the crowd   

I'd track down these versions to start:
2015 KCRW The Waterfall show
2015 Masonic Auditorium, San Francisco Night 2
2015 One Big Holiday Night 3  (my personal favorite)
2016 Austin City Limits
2017 One Big Holiday Night 3
2018 One Big Holiday Night 3

I do not recommend the 2015 Red Rocks version.  It was sandwiched into Steam Engine, and you really miss out on getting the real OMR experience.

[crooney]

i love the 2015 masonic version of only memories.  just killer.

[sillyboob]

Two things I love about Never In The Real World...

That opening riff reminds me of the opening of Sturgill's cover of 'The Promise'.

The huge way the band comes in about one minute into the song.  Love that with headphones on.

[Lucius]

Are there any recordings of Only Memories out there where the crowd doesn't talk through it? Such a pretty song and I love the way it builds up live but I've never managed to find a taping where I'm not sitting there thinking "shut up shut up SHUT UP" about the crowd   

I'd track down these versions to start:
2015 KCRW The Waterfall show
2015 Masonic Auditorium, San Francisco Night 2
2015 One Big Holiday Night 3  (my personal favorite)
2016 Austin City Limits
2017 One Big Holiday Night 3
2018 One Big Holiday Night 3

I do not recommend the 2015 Red Rocks version.  It was sandwiched into Steam Engine, and you really miss out on getting the real OMR experience.

That Steam > Only Memories > Steam if it's the same one I remember was a painful listen. What was shaping up to potentially be an all time great Steam ruined by a few minutes of the crowd talking through OMR right in the middle of it why do people feel the need to have full blown conversations at concerts? It really infuriates me! That San Fran version is great though. Why didn't they think to build the song up like that in the studio?

Back over in "Self Titled" land. I was with a friend recently and during a Spotify Shuffle 'Love Love Love' came on and the friend LOVED it. Have also witnessed a couple of celebs I follow on Twitter post it. She's got appeal that one!

[RobRoy286]

Are there any recordings of Only Memories out there where the crowd doesn't talk through it? Such a pretty song and I love the way it builds up live but I've never managed to find a taping where I'm not sitting there thinking "shut up shut up SHUT UP" about the crowd   

I'd track down these versions to start:
2015 KCRW The Waterfall show
2015 Masonic Auditorium, San Francisco Night 2
2015 One Big Holiday Night 3  (my personal favorite)
2016 Austin City Limits
2017 One Big Holiday Night 3
2018 One Big Holiday Night 3

I do not recommend the 2015 Red Rocks version.  It was sandwiched into Steam Engine, and you really miss out on getting the real OMR experience.

That Steam > Only Memories > Steam if it's the same one I remember was a painful listen. What was shaping up to potentially be an all time great Steam ruined by a few minutes of the crowd talking through OMR right in the middle of it why do people feel the need to have full blown conversations at concerts? It really infuriates me! That San Fran version is great though. Why didn't they think to build the song up like that in the studio?

Back over in "Self Titled" land. I was with a friend recently and during a Spotify Shuffle 'Love Love Love' came on and the friend LOVED it. Have also witnessed a couple of celebs I follow on Twitter post it. She's got appeal that one!

That Steam/Memories/Steam/Phone run is one of my favorite recordings ever! Different strokes I guess.

[MMJTX]

That 2015 Red Rocks show was my first time at Red Rocks, in the moment i remember kind of being bummed they stuck it in there during my first Steam Engine as well. but now i love it and listen to it often.

[Lucius]

I love the idea of it but it's the crowd talking throughout the OMR segment that bums me out. Stuff like that really grates on me. If they've done it more than once there's every chance I'm talking about a taping from another night though!

[sillyboob]

That 2015 Red Rocks show was my first time at Red Rocks, in the moment i remember kind of being bummed they stuck it in there during my first Steam Engine as well. but now i love it and listen to it often.

That was my first Red Rocks as well.  I too was (and still am) bummed about the shortened version of Only Memories Remain, especially after the stellar spaced out version at One Big Holiday.  I even split the song into two separate files, with the truncated OMR first, then I combined the two Steam parts into one track as the next song.  I'm weird, what can I say.

All that being said, what an epic first Red Rocks show!  Was absolutely exhausted after flying in from LA that day, then the epic 28 song set.  Caught Alabama Shakes with the Drive-by Truckers two nights later.