My Morning Jacket

My Morning Jacket => The Music => Topic started by: The DARK on Feb 03, 2007, 08:18 PM

Title: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 03, 2007, 08:18 PM
Part 1 is said and done! Here's the final results:

1. One Big Holiday  
2. Phone Went West                
3. All Night Long              
4. The Pina Colada Song              
5.  Dancefloors              
6.  Tyrone              
7.  Steam Engine (Jim Acoustic)              
8.  bY mY cAR            
9.  The War Begun            
10. Wordless Chorus                
11. Lowdown                
12. Cobra                
13. They Ran                
14. Off The Record          
15. Dondante          
16. O Is The One That Is Real          
17. You're a Big Girl Now        
18. Can You See The Hard Helmet On My Head?        
19. Rollin' Back                
20. Come Closer        
21. Master Plan      
22. Fade Into You      
23. Lay Low    
24. Just Because I Do    
25. I Will Be There When You Die      
26. I Needed It Most    
27. At Dawn    
28. Xmas Curtain    
29. Anytime  
30. Run Thru  
31. Mahgeetah  
32. Weeks Go By Like Days  
33. Where to Begin  
34. Golden
35. It's About Twilight Now

Now for part 2: Choosing an order. We will decide this collectively. What do we want as the opener?
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: DaFunkyPrecedent on Feb 04, 2007, 01:33 AM
wordless chorus...such a wonderful way to open the show.  He sings in pitch black, then BOOM the chorus hits and My Morning Jacket is alive.  no better song to open with...in my opinion.
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: Ghosts_on_TV on Feb 04, 2007, 02:55 AM
OBH is the best opener that they will ever have...
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: dragonboy on Feb 04, 2007, 03:14 AM
QuoteOBH is the best opener that they will ever have...
I personally think that OBH is too big a song to open with (sorry Ghosts, I'm not intentionally disagreeing with everything you say today!)
I'm going to agree with DaFunk & give Wordless my vote!
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: Ghosts_on_TV on Feb 04, 2007, 03:28 AM
Quote
QuoteOBH is the best opener that they will ever have...
I personally think that OBH is too big a song to open with (sorry Ghosts, I'm not intentionally disagreeing with everything you say today!)
I'm going to agree with DaFunk & give Wordless my vote!

It's all good, DB. You have your opinions and I have mine.  (even though I am right...http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j_ZMh_3Byrk)

I am biased though, I was at this show.   :D
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: dragonboy on Feb 04, 2007, 03:34 AM
I thought you were drunk & going to bed?!!  ;)

Thanks for the clip, I saw Alice In Chains do the same thing with the white sheet years & years ago at a tiny little club in London...
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: Ghosts_on_TV on Feb 04, 2007, 03:38 AM
QuoteI thought you were drunk & going to bed?!!  ;)

Thanks for the clip, I saw Alice In Chains do the same thing with the white sheet years & years ago at a tiny little club in London...

I'm drunk and (should be) in bed at the moment.  :D
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: EAZYE on Feb 04, 2007, 03:59 AM
WORDLESS!!!!  Cuz when those lights hit 8-)
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 04, 2007, 01:30 PM
I think Wordless should close the first set. One Big Holiday would work in any other setlist, but with a lot of slow-burners and rarities in this set, I don't think it will work here. I say open with Twilight at twilight!
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: darkglow on Feb 04, 2007, 03:14 PM
dum... dum dum dum dum dum.. dum.. dum dum dum dum dum.. it's about TWILIGHT NOW...  followed by MASTERPLAN.. and then fading the end of Masterplan into Wordless
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The Big Come Up on Feb 04, 2007, 03:22 PM
Wordless (great opener)
Lowdown (not as fast so a good warmup)
One Big Holiday (Rock and Roll!)
Dancefloors
Masterplan
All Night Long
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: DaFunkyPrecedent on Feb 04, 2007, 03:49 PM
dancefloors and easy morning rebel need to be back to back...horn section ya knows?  is easy morning rebel even on the list??? if its not, thats a shame, a damn shame.
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: DaFunkyPrecedent on Feb 04, 2007, 03:53 PM
PS...we should think about what are the most danceable songs and putting a few of those together...perferably towards the end of the show.  that makes it funnnnnnn!
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 04, 2007, 04:13 PM
From what I hear, it should either be Twilight or Wordless. What do we want?
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: BH on Feb 04, 2007, 04:19 PM
I say you have to take whoever puts in first.  It may not be what everyone thinks is right but that will be part of the fun.

Song #2  OFF THE RECORD  (Since there is no it beats 4 u)
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 04, 2007, 04:25 PM
I suppose you are right...otherwise this thread would never end. (I'd like that though.)
Still, if a lot of people object, which on these boards shouldn't happen, we should be able to take it back. Still, Wordless has every right to be an opener. I would like Off The Record later in the setlist, but I suppose it will work second.
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: MMJCOBRA on Feb 05, 2007, 01:23 PM
I know i'm new ' round here but At Dawn makes an excellent opener, understated, cool and it has a nice mellow intro to warm you up for the journey to follow.

peace
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: aMD on Feb 05, 2007, 04:12 PM
either at dawn or the dark are my favorite openers because of good memories of these songs (especially at dawn).  Off the Record isn't on the setlist so I don't think it should be number 2.
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 05, 2007, 04:59 PM
Off The Record is on the setlist. Number 14.

P.S. Welcome Unravelled!
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 05, 2007, 09:35 PM
Well, I suppose BH is right. We need to do this in an orderly fasion. So we've decided that Wordless opens and Off the Record comes next. Let's get some general opinions on songs though: Which NEED to go together?
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The Big Come Up on Feb 05, 2007, 09:49 PM
I would put Masterplan and One Big Holiday as the next two. They come in order on the album, and master is a bit slower and builds up, which is a perfect precurser to OBH
Twilight Should come whenever the sun goes down, or if the set starts at like 10 then close to the end
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 05, 2007, 09:57 PM
I agree, TBCU. Here's what we've got so far:

1. Wordless Chorus
2. Off the Record
3. Masterplan
4. One Big Holiday

:D
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The Big Come Up on Feb 05, 2007, 10:02 PM
Dark what do you think next, some accoustic (Steam Engine, By My Car) or Lowdown/Xmas Curtain (slower but still pretty rockin)
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 05, 2007, 10:45 PM
Let's do Lowdown/Xmas Curtain. Don't want to slow down the pace too much yet.
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 06, 2007, 09:32 PM
I'm also going to say Rollin' Back at #7. So we've got...

1. Wordless Chorus
2. Off the Record
3. Master Plan
4. One Big Holiday
5. Lowdown
6. Xmas Curtain
7. Rollin' Back
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: Ghosts_on_TV on Feb 06, 2007, 09:56 PM
Dancefloors
Phone Went West
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 06, 2007, 10:13 PM
Lay Low
War Begun

1. Wordless Chorus
2. Off the Record
3. Master Plan
4. One Big Holiday
5. Lowdown
6. Xmas Curtain
7. Rollin' Back
8. Dancefloors
9. Phone Went West
10. Lay Low
11. War Begun

Looks great so far!
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 08, 2007, 10:57 PM
Just keeping the thread alive...
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: EAZYE on Feb 09, 2007, 04:25 PM
At Dawn
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 09, 2007, 07:20 PM
Just Because I Do

1. Wordless Chorus  
2. Off the Record  
3. Master Plan  
4. One Big Holiday  
5. Lowdown  
6. Xmas Curtain  
7. Rollin' Back
8. Dancefloors
9. Phone Went West
10. Lay Low
11. War Begun
12. At Dawn
13. Just Because I Do
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: ChiefOKONO on Feb 09, 2007, 07:21 PM
1. Wordless Chorus  
2. Off the Record  
3. Master Plan  
4. One Big Holiday  
5. Lowdown  
6. Xmas Curtain  
7. Rollin' Back  
8. Dancefloors  
9. Phone Went West  
10. Lay Low  
11. War Begun
12. At Dawn
13. Just Because I Do
14. Chills
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 09, 2007, 07:23 PM
Sorry Chief, Chills isn't on there.  :(

1. Wordless Chorus  
2. Off the Record  
3. Master Plan  
4. One Big Holiday  
5. Lowdown  
6. Xmas Curtain  
7. Rollin' Back  
8. Dancefloors  
9. Phone Went West  
10. Lay Low  
11. War Begun
12. At Dawn
13. Just Because I Do

And here's another posting of the songs we chose...

1. One Big Holiday    
2. Phone Went West                
3. All Night Long              
4. The Pina Colada Song              
5.  Dancefloors              
6.  Tyrone              
7.  Steam Engine (Jim Acoustic)              
8.  bY mY cAR            
9.  The War Begun            
10. Wordless Chorus                
11. Lowdown                
12. Cobra                
13. They Ran                
14. Off The Record          
15. Dondante          
16. O Is The One That Is Real          
17. You're a Big Girl Now        
18. Can You See The Hard Helmet On My Head?        
19. Rollin' Back                
20. Come Closer          
21. Master Plan        
22. Fade Into You      
23. Lay Low      
24. Just Because I Do      
25. I Will Be There When You Die      
26. I Needed It Most      
27. At Dawn      
28. Xmas Curtain    
29. Anytime    
30. Run Thru  
31. Mahgeetah  
32. Weeks Go By Like Days  
33. Where to Begin  
34. Golden  
35. It's About Twilight Now
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The Big Come Up on Feb 09, 2007, 07:34 PM
Its soul time! Tyrone and All Night Long=Dance the night away.
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 09, 2007, 07:37 PM
...Followed by Cobra and Dondante!  :D

1. Wordless Chorus    
2. Off the Record    
3. Master Plan    
4. One Big Holiday    
5. Lowdown    
6. Xmas Curtain    
7. Rollin' Back    
8. Dancefloors    
9. Phone Went West    
10. Lay Low    
11. War Begun  
12. At Dawn  
13. Just Because I Do
14. Tyrone
15. All Night Long
16. Cobra
17. Dondante
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: BH on Feb 09, 2007, 08:22 PM
I suggest, in keeping with normal MMJ procedure, that the covers are grouped together into two groups at the most.   But then again, this is our setlist isn't it?   We can do whatever we want!
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 09, 2007, 08:28 PM
Exactly! MMJ will probably never play Tyrone, Weeks Go By Like Days, or Hard Helmet ever again, but maybe starting threads like this will help them see how much we want them played. Do you think MMJ ever looks at the forum? I think they might...
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: BH on Feb 10, 2007, 12:28 AM
Patrick used to be on all the time.  It wasn't that long ago that he dropped in.

And I am actually Jim, posing as an aging white male from suburbia with a wife and kids that likes to make really bad jokes on the internet.  
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: sweatboard on Feb 10, 2007, 12:45 AM
Let's just put it this way, IF the band ever looks at this forum they most likely just roll their eyes at all the aging white dudes makeing really bad jokes on the internet.  I'm willing to bet they don't come here for setlist ideas, but who knows.  The fact of the matter is, unless they play the Pina Colada song it could all just be coincedence.  The day they play "Escape" we will know with out a doubt that the band not only reads the forum but hold us in high regard.  
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 10, 2007, 09:08 AM
Don't be so sure. I remember a thread just before the first OKONOKOS show where we predicted the opener. I heard a few people say The Bear and The Dark. And look what they opened with! And if I were a band member, I'd find it hard not to look at what people were saying about us.
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: sweatboard on Feb 12, 2007, 04:41 PM
I double dog dare someone else to try this.  This is my ultimate arrangement.  I want to see what someone else comes up with.

p.s. I switched out "Pina Colada Song" with "Stranglehold" because I was the one who picked it to begin with and it really just doesn't work in this setlist.


1. At Dawn
2. Masterplan
3. Lowdown
4. One Big Holliday
5. Off the Record
6. Cobra
7. Worldless
8. O is the one
9. Dancefloors
10. Lay Low
11. Just Because I do
12. Steam Engine
13. By My car
14. Phone Went West
15. Tyrone
16. They Ran
17. Where to Begin
18. Don Dante
19. I'll be there when you die
20. I needed it most
21. War begun
22. run thru

encore

23. Golden
24. Fade Into You
25. Come Closer
26. Weeks Go By Like Days
27. Rollin back
28. X-Mas Curtain
29. Can you see the hard helmet
30. You're a big girl now
31. It's About Twilight Now
32. Stranglehold (The Nudge)
33. Mahgeetah
34. Anytime
35. All Night Long


Encore

36. Tommy
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: Ghosts_on_TV on Feb 12, 2007, 07:40 PM
QuoteI double dog dare someone else to try this.  This is my ultimate arrangement.  I want to see what someone else comes up with.

p.s. I switched out "Pina Colada Song" with "Stranglehold" because I was the one who picked it to begin with and it really just doesn't work in this setlist.


1. At Dawn
2. Masterplan
3. Lowdown
4. One Big Holliday
5. Off the Record
6. Cobra
7. Worldless
8. O is the one
9. Dancefloors
10. Lay Low
11. Just Because I do
12. Steam Engine
13. By My car
14. Phone Went West
15. Tyrone
16. They Ran
17. Where to Begin
18. Don Dante
19. I'll be there when you die
20. I needed it most
21. War begun
22. run thru

encore

23. Golden
24. Fade Into You
25. Come Closer
26. Weeks Go By Like Days
27. Rollin back
28. X-Mas Curtain
29. Can you see the hard helmet
30. You're a big girl now
31. It's About Twilight Now
32. Stranglehold (The Nudge)
33. Mahgeetah
34. Anytime
35. All Night Long


Encore

36. Tommy

Um...yeah I'd say that looks damn near perfect. I'd maybe maybe switch Fade into you and Golden, but that would be it.
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 12, 2007, 09:15 PM
And also swap Masterplan and Lowdown.

Here's mine:
1. It's About Twilight Now
2. Dancefloors
3. Masterplan
4. One Big Holiday
5. Off The Record
6. Rollin' Back
7. O Is The One That Is Real
8. Lowdown
9. Lay Low
10. War Begun
11. Can You See The Hard Helmet On My Head?
12. Weeks Go By Like Days
13. Xmas Curtain
14. Cobra
15. Dondante
16. Run Thru
17. They Ran

SET BREAK

18. I Will Be There When You Die (Jim Solo)
19. I Needed It Most (Jim Solo)
20. By My Car (Jim Solo)
21. At Dawn
22. Just Because I Do
23. Tyrone
24. All Night Long
25. Fade Into You
26. You're A Big Girl Now
27. Golden
28. Where To Begin
29. Come Closer
30. Phone Went West
31. Wordless Chorus
32. Anytime
33. Mahgeetah
34. Stranglehold
35. Steam Engine (Jim Solo)
Title: Re: Bonnaroo Setlist Game, Part 2
Post by: The DARK on Feb 20, 2007, 11:27 PM
bump

Seriously, let's get this done!