My Morning Jacket

My Morning Jacket => The Music => Topic started by: Ruckus on Jul 28, 2010, 03:17 PM

Title: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Jul 28, 2010, 03:17 PM
On my computer.  Looking forward to listening to this.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: My Monkey Friend on Jul 28, 2010, 03:48 PM
anyone have any idea what this album sounds like? i am sure I will buy it anyways, but i am curious.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Jul 28, 2010, 03:58 PM
Quoteanyone have any idea what this album sounds like? i am sure I will buy it anyways, but i am curious.
So far so good.  It's Carl.  Have you heard any of his other solo stuff.

First track, instrumental.  Second is a straight forward country folk ditty

I don't know what else I can tell ya.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Jul 28, 2010, 03:59 PM
QuoteOn my computer.  Looking forward to listening to this.


Did you get the bonus tracks?   My download did not have them, and a couple tracks were out of order.  I think there was an issue.  I sent an e-mail to topspin.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Jul 28, 2010, 04:02 PM
Quote
QuoteOn my computer.  Looking forward to listening to this.


Did you get the bonus tracks?   My download did not have them, and a couple tracks were out of order.  I think there was an issue.  I sent an e-mail to topspin.

Yeah, though I haven't gotten to them yet.  How many were there again?  I got 2 bonus tracks

I got 11 tracks plus two bonus
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Jul 28, 2010, 04:05 PM
Ahh, you are correct BH.  I'm missing tracks five and six plus at least a bunus track I believe
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Jul 28, 2010, 04:09 PM
QuoteAhh, you are correct BH.  I'm missing tracks five and six plus at least a bunus track I believe

Ahh, I see now BH.  Enough and Heaven knows weren't numbered but I got them.  I didn't get any of the three bonus tracks.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Crispy on Jul 28, 2010, 04:24 PM
I ordered the whole shebang about 5 seconds after getting the email, and STILL haven't gotten any emails or anything telling me how to download the goods. ARGH  :-/
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Jul 28, 2010, 04:26 PM
QuoteI ordered the whole shebang about 5 seconds after getting the email, and STILL haven't gotten any emails or anything telling me how to download the goods. ARGH  :-/

There's a link that you should have been able to hit.  I got a zip file with the album with a follow up email.  Maybe they are fixing the issue right now after BH emailed them or something.  I downloaded mine two hours ago I think.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Jul 28, 2010, 04:30 PM
Yeah, there was a link for me no e-mail.  Crispy the link was on the page right after the order was confirmed.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Crispy on Jul 28, 2010, 04:39 PM
QuoteYeah, there was a link for me no e-mail.  Crispy the link was on the page right after the order was confirmed.
In which I missed the link and immediately closed. Grrrr. Thanks for the info, though, we'll see if customer support can help me out.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Jul 28, 2010, 05:01 PM
Quote
QuoteYeah, there was a link for me no e-mail.  Crispy the link was on the page right after the order was confirmed.
In which I missed the link and immediately closed. Grrrr. Thanks for the info, though, we'll see if customer support can help me out.

Let me know if not.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: mahg33ta on Jul 28, 2010, 05:23 PM
I downloaded through the link fine (although ALMOST closed out before it caught my eye)   but got none of the bonus tracks.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Crispy on Jul 28, 2010, 05:40 PM
Weird stuff. Customer support set me up with a link to a zip file calling itself "All Birds Say Deluxe Edition.zip", but also no bonus tracks.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Jul 28, 2010, 05:50 PM
The guy at topspin has been very helpful.  This is the latest correspondence....

[size=14]After digging into the matter, we've determined that all 11 album tracks WERE included -- the file names just didn't have the track numbers. Enough and To No One are tracks 5 and 6 from the album.

The bonus tracks that were to be included are missing, so we're working with the artist to make sure these get to fans.

Thanks for your patience,

[/size]
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: johnnYYac on Jul 28, 2010, 07:30 PM
QuoteThe guy at topspin has been very helpful.  This is the latest correspondence....

[size=14]After digging into the matter, we've determined that all 11 album tracks WERE included -- the file names just didn't have the track numbers. Enough and To No One are tracks 5 and 6 from the album.

The bonus tracks that were to be included are missing, so we're working with the artist to make sure these get to fans.

Thanks for your patience,

[/size]

Thanks for looking into it.  I hadn't checked out the zip file yet.  Looking forward to it once I get my monkeys to bed.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: SmokinShootin on Jul 29, 2010, 02:47 AM
I've only listened to it once, but I really like it. I will have to listen to it a few more time before I can tell to what degree I like the album.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Jul 29, 2010, 05:48 AM
How do we get the download of the extra videos and footage from the deluxe edition?
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: mahg33ta on Jul 29, 2010, 09:21 AM
check your email if you didn't get the bonus tracks - got an email resolving it this am....

Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Jul 29, 2010, 11:21 PM
Finally just finished the album.  Beautiful.  I guess it's not something that's going to blow most people away on first listen but this one is definately going to be a grower.  Can't wait to listen outside on a nice day.  All kinds of wonderful sounds in this one.


Retired is an early favorite.  It sounds like this to me:

(http://www.areavoices.com/astrobob/images/Moon_bright_wide.jpg)
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Mr.BigSig on Jul 29, 2010, 11:40 PM
QuoteI've only listened to it once, but I really like it. I will have to listen to it a few more time before I can tell to what degree I like the album.
That signature is totally messing with my web browsing expirience.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Jul 30, 2010, 09:33 AM
QuoteFinally just finished the album.  Beautiful.  I guess it's not something that's going to blow most people away on first listen but this one is definately going to be a grower.  Can't wait to listen outside on a nice day.  All kinds of wonderful sounds in this one.


Retired is an early favorite.  It sounds like this to me:

(http://www.areavoices.com/astrobob/images/Moon_bright_wide.jpg)
Retired is awesome. Nice pic to go with it. There is a live version from the Spin Indy bootleg. It used to be listed as Return but they seem to have changed it.

http://www.musicalfamilytree.com/band/carl_broemel

Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Jul 30, 2010, 09:37 AM
QuoteHow do we get the download of the extra [highlight]videos and footage[/highlight] from the deluxe edition?
It's odd quoting myself.
Does anyone know about this?
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: CC on Jul 30, 2010, 10:30 AM
Quote
QuoteHow do we get the download of the extra [highlight]videos and footage[/highlight] from the deluxe edition?
It's odd quoting myself.
Does anyone know about this?

i'm pretty sure these will get released at the same time as the physical release.

Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Pork Soda on Jul 30, 2010, 03:05 PM
it's a pretty enjoyable listen. the music is really good, some of the lyrics however are kinda goofy, borderline embarassing. had trouble finishing the different people song (forget the title) because of how annoying the chorus and lyrics were...but overall it's pretty good. i love the song "carried away" which i had the privelage of hearing live at merriweather in the spring.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Jul 30, 2010, 04:13 PM
embarrassing for who?
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: MMJ_fanatic on Aug 02, 2010, 01:36 AM
Waiting for my super creamy deluxe version to show up in my mailbox (or driveway depending on the delivery method..)
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: My Monkey Friend on Aug 04, 2010, 03:44 PM
i am a tech idiot- if i download the album, can i move it to itunes somehow?
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: mahg33ta on Aug 05, 2010, 07:38 AM
Quoteit's a pretty enjoyable listen. the music is really good, some of the lyrics however are kinda goofy, borderline embarassing. had trouble finishing the different people song (forget the title) because of how annoying the chorus and lyrics were...but overall it's pretty good. i love the song "carried away" which i had the privelage of hearing live at merriweather in the spring.

I listened to the album in the car with my wife, and about halfway through she said "is this a children's album?" which made me wince.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: johnnYYac on Aug 05, 2010, 08:26 AM
I think I do like "Lose What's Left" a bit better than "All Birds Say".  It has more upbeat energy.  ABS is very mellow.  I could see what Mrs. mahg33ta is saying.  

This album deserves multiple listens.  I've listened to it 3 or 4 times and it blends into the background.  I'm always in my car, too, which might affect the experience.  I'm listening to it now, as I write this, so it is a more focused experience.

Someone remarked on some of the lyrics being "embarassing", or something to that effect.  I guess every album has a few awkward tunes (Two Halves, anyone?).  They may grow on you, or you can hit "Skip".  

I find ABS emminently listenable.  The instrumentation is fantastic; we all knew Carl was talented.  I'm digging it.

I also totally respect that he's making music that is not necessarily going to fit the tastes of My Morning Jacket fans.  That takes BALLS, as it could hurt sales.  You listen to this gentle album, then watch him rock out on stage w/MMJ.  "There's a lot of different people in the world."
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Aug 06, 2010, 09:23 AM
Quote

I find ABS emminently listenable.  The instrumentation is fantastic; we all knew Carl was talented.  I'm digging it.

I also totally respect that he's making music that is not necessarily going to fit the tastes of My Morning Jacket fans.  That takes BALLS, as it could hurt sales.  You listen to this gentle album, then watch him rock out on stage w/MMJ.  "There's a lot of different people in the world."
I totally agree with this.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Aug 26, 2010, 11:51 PM
Nice...Looking forward to the Carl gift pack to arrive.  Signed vinyl and a way too small t-shirt. ;D
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Aug 27, 2010, 09:05 AM
I know the live versions of Carried Away and Enough had already been posted so here's Questions too:

http://vimeo.com/14037111
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Aug 27, 2010, 10:49 AM
Nice!  I'm loving this album.  It makes me feel happy.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Aug 27, 2010, 11:45 AM
Carl's gone all Andrew Birdy on us!  Love the looping on this version and the freakout at the end!   Can someone make an mp3 of this?  VIMEO videos always play choppy for me or I would do it myself.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: johnnYYac on Aug 27, 2010, 12:49 PM
QuoteCarl's gone all Andrew Birdy on us!  Love the looping on this version and the freakout at the end!   Can someone make an mp3 of this?  VIMEO videos always play choppy for me or I would do it myself.
I'll try when I get home, unless someone beats me to it.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: johnnYYac on Aug 28, 2010, 03:45 PM
I got my collector's edition of All Birds Say today!  #1 of 250!  Nice package; too bad I don't own a turntable.

BH, here's a link to the mp3 of that Vimeo presentation of Carl's "Questions" via Freecorder:

http://www.megaupload.com/?d=4N1C5KOP
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: searchinbig on Aug 28, 2010, 04:33 PM
Yup just got mine today also. A nice surprise. First class job with the packaging. Johnny, it's not # 1. Mine says "This is 1 of an edition of 250". I thought I got the first one also.

Just a side, if you don't have this and there are still some left, do yourself a BIG favor and order it!
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Im The Dude on Aug 28, 2010, 11:53 PM
QuoteYup just got mine today also. A nice surprise. First class job with the packaging. Johnny, it's not # 1. Mine says "This is 1 of an edition of 250". I thought I got the first one also.

Just a side, if you don't have this and there are still some left, do yourself a BIG favor and order it!

I was going to ask that same thing. I thought I had Number 1....haha.

Listened to the vinyl today....amazing. Joe's Pub show will be sweet.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Aug 29, 2010, 12:14 AM
QuoteI got my collector's edition of All Birds Say today!  #1 of 250!  Nice package; too bad I don't own a turntable.

BH, here's a link to the mp3 of that Vimeo presentation of Carl's "Questions" via Freecorder:

http://www.megaupload.com/?d=4N1C5KOP

Thanks JY.  You friggin' rock.  Always helping out.   You're getting a drink in NYC.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Aug 30, 2010, 12:29 AM
QuoteYup just got mine today also. A nice surprise. First class job with the packaging. Johnny, it's not # 1. Mine says "This is 1 of an edition of 250". I thought I got the first one also.

Just a side, if you don't have this and there are still some left, do yourself a BIG favor and order it!
I can't wait to get mine. I ordered it the day it was put up on the site too though I imagine it may take a while to get here.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Aug 30, 2010, 01:26 PM
Definitely a nice treat to find this in my mailbox today.  I completely agree with everyone that the packaging was very well done.  I'm rocking my smextra smedium tshirt right now.  This form fitting shirt is not flattering on my man breasts. :-/ ;D.

It's one of those I wanna play the record but I hate messing with signed stuff deals.  
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: scosby2 on Aug 30, 2010, 01:29 PM
i forgot to order this a few months back and I was just gonna order the regular vinyl and cd a second ago but the limited edition is still not sold out so what the heck...might as well
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Aug 31, 2010, 08:03 AM
I found some recent interviews:
http://www.writersonprocess.com/2010/08/broemel.html

http://www.jambands.com/features/2010/08/30/carried-away-by-my-morning-jacket-s-carl-broemel?1

http://www.courier-journal.com/article/20100831/SCENE04/308310014

Enjoi! :)
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Aug 31, 2010, 08:54 AM
QuoteI found some recent interviews:
http://www.writersonprocess.com/2010/08/broemel.html

http://www.jambands.com/features/2010/08/30/carried-away-by-my-morning-jacket-s-carl-broemel?1

http://www.courier-journal.com/article/20100831/SCENE04/308310014

Enjoi! :)

Thanks Weenie. :)  I paricularly enjoyed the jambands.com piece.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: johnnYYac on Aug 31, 2010, 12:40 PM
Quotei forgot to order this a few months back and I was just gonna order the regular vinyl and cd a second ago but the limited edition is still not sold out so what the heck...might as well

Definitely, Seth.  Its a nice package (and I don't even own a turntable, to my wife's frustration).  I wanted the Carl sig.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Sep 01, 2010, 02:01 PM
Carl is on Lighting100 right now!

http://lightning100.com/
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Sep 02, 2010, 04:40 AM
QuoteCarl is on Lighting100 right now!

http://lightning100.com/
Great. I missed it.
Was it this?

http://lightning100.com/2010/08/31/carl-broemel-interview/
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Sep 02, 2010, 09:34 AM
Quote
QuoteCarl is on Lighting100 right now!

http://lightning100.com/
Great. I missed it.
Was it this?

http://lightning100.com/2010/08/31/carl-broemel-interview/

That's it!  I didn't see the video, just the audio thanks!

I'm falling in love with this album.  In The Garden is my new favorite.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: mike on Sep 02, 2010, 05:24 PM
Thanks for the link to the interview. I enjoyed that, Carl is really soft spoken. Enjoying the record very much as well. Way to go Carl.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: el_chode on Sep 02, 2010, 05:51 PM
Anyone else familiar with Marc Mulcahy or whatever his last name is from Polaris?

I love the guitar tone they both have, the warmth really surrounds you
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: searchinbig on Sep 02, 2010, 06:35 PM
QuoteCarl is on Lighting100 right now!

http://lightning100.com/


Here's the audio if you guys want it!

http://www.sendspace.com/file/qqpols
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: scosby2 on Sep 02, 2010, 09:52 PM
to my astonishment my vinyl came today!! it only took three days to get here from the time i ordered it. i definitely know why he mentioned the vinyl in the lightning 100 interview yesterday. it sounds great!! the shirt is awesome too and mine fits great!!  i debated for a while about leaving it alone and not playing it but i eventually caved...it was a good decision
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: tdb810 on Sep 05, 2010, 12:57 PM
this is perfect lazy sunday morning music......loving this right now !!  can't wait to lounge out at joe's pub and enjoy these tunes live.
it will be an absolutely perfect venue for this album...i may wear a cocktail dress :-)
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Im The Dude on Sep 05, 2010, 01:48 PM
Quotethis is perfect lazy sunday morning music......loving this right now !!  can't wait to lounge out at joe's pub and enjoy these tunes live.
it will be an absolutely perfect venue for this album...i may wear a cocktail dress :-)

Do you think he'll play the whole album? Will he be with a full band? I can't wait to hear this live too. I love the vinyl edition. Got my on the 28th. Sounds amazing.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: tdb810 on Sep 05, 2010, 02:18 PM
Quote
Quotethis is perfect lazy sunday morning music......loving this right now !!  can't wait to lounge out at joe's pub and enjoy these tunes live.
it will be an absolutely perfect venue for this album...i may wear a cocktail dress :-)

Do you think he'll play the whole album? Will he be with a full band? I can't wait to hear this live too. I love the vinyl edition. Got my on the 28th. Sounds amazing.

I sure hope he will! No clue about the rest of the fellas...but one can dream :)

Would love to hear the vinyl, but settled for electronic.  We have 2 turntables in the basement but sadly alone and untouched they sit :)  some day when I get thru all of the other projects in my house!


Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ghosts_on_TV on Sep 05, 2010, 06:42 PM
I just realized that I got 2 CDs with the deluxe package, the packaged cd and one with the vinyl.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Sep 05, 2010, 11:30 PM
QuoteI just realized that I got 2 CDs with the deluxe package, the packaged cd and one with the vinyl.
Me too!

Here's the Videoclip for Heaven Knows:
(scroll down a bit)

http://www.spin.com/articles/my-morning-jackets-broemel-talks-solo-album
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Sep 07, 2010, 12:12 AM
Quote
Quoteit's a pretty enjoyable listen. the music is really good, some of the lyrics however are kinda goofy, borderline embarassing. had trouble finishing the different people song (forget the title) because of how annoying the chorus and lyrics were...but overall it's pretty good. i love the song "carried away" which i had the privelage of hearing live at merriweather in the spring.

[highlight]I listened to the album in the car with my wife, and about halfway through she said "is this a children's album?" which made me wince.[/highlight]

I've gave this album two hard listens today and I chuckled remembering you writing something before about it, quoted above.  Isn't that great? ;D  You can dig it and play it for the kiddies.  The album has grown on me a bunch.  There is such a purity and naivete about it that I think/hope will translate well in the intimate setting that will be Joe's.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: tdb810 on Sep 07, 2010, 09:04 PM
Quote
Quote
Quoteit's a pretty enjoyable listen. the music is really good, some of the lyrics however are kinda goofy, borderline embarassing. had trouble finishing the different people song (forget the title) because of how annoying the chorus and lyrics were...but overall it's pretty good. i love the song "carried away" which i had the privelage of hearing live at merriweather in the spring.

[highlight]I listened to the album in the car with my wife, and about halfway through she said "is this a children's album?" which made me wince.[/highlight]

I've gave this album two hard listens today and I chuckled remembering you writing something before about it, quoted above.  Isn't that great? ;D  You can dig it and play it for the kiddies.  The album has grown on me a bunch.  There is such a purity and naivete about it that I think/hope will translate well in the intimate setting that will be Joe's.

what ruckus said :)

my (7 yo) daughter was listening to it with me while she was crafting friendship bracelets on sunday...and seemed to be humming along at certain points.  all "wince"ing aside...i loved that!
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Erik26 on Sep 15, 2010, 07:44 PM
My copy finally showed up today!! After the first listen I really like it. Different People stands out for me so far.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: johnnYYac on Sep 15, 2010, 08:17 PM
Quote
Quote
Quote
Quoteit's a pretty enjoyable listen. the music is really good, some of the lyrics however are kinda goofy, borderline embarassing. had trouble finishing the different people song (forget the title) because of how annoying the chorus and lyrics were...but overall it's pretty good. i love the song "carried away" which i had the privelage of hearing live at merriweather in the spring.

[highlight]I listened to the album in the car with my wife, and about halfway through she said "is this a children's album?" which made me wince.[/highlight]

I've gave this album two hard listens today and I chuckled remembering you writing something before about it, quoted above.  Isn't that great? ;D  You can dig it and play it for the kiddies.  The album has grown on me a bunch.  There is such a purity and naivete about it that I think/hope will translate well in the intimate setting that will be Joe's.

what ruckus said :)

my (7 yo) daughter was listening to it with me while she was crafting friendship bracelets on sunday...and seemed to be humming along at certain points.  all "wince"ing aside...i loved that!
On a similar note, I picked up my 2 year old Lauren from daycare last week.  One of her teachers said Lauren had been singing a song all day and no one could figure out what it was.  When they asked her, she said something like Seem Binsen.

On the drive home, I asked her to sing me the song.  I almost drove off the road!  I tried to record it later at home, but she wouldn't stop playing with the pop filter.

It sounded something like this...

"So, I do beeve none is fisicoo not me.

Its not da deets!  make you week!  Not da night!  Make you seep!"

It goes on!  I am so happy everytime she does it, and only 2!!!  If I can get her to let me record it without messing with the mic, I'll post it.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: ynwa on Sep 15, 2010, 11:27 PM
i really like this album.  listened to it on repeat one night & it's just so pleasant sounding.  i seem to quietly sing and hum "questions"  to myself randomly, so i suppose that's my favorite, for now.

re: "different people" - from carl's website (and the liner notes): "written by earl lett (beantown music BMI) additional lyrics by carl broemel"  so, maybe earl lett wrote the ,err, embarassing ones???

http://carlbroemel.com/web/lyrics/

my lithograph info also reads "This is 1 of an Edition of 250" & until i read thru these other posts, i really thought mine was #1 of 250.  when i opened it i thought "geez, i didn't think i was that quick on the draw".  hahaha!
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: ralph on Oct 17, 2010, 09:30 PM
I really enjoy this record a lot. Was taken with it on the first listen.

The comments about it being good for kids amuses me. I often comment that Brian Wilson's SMiLE is The Wiggles for grown ups, so at least All Birds Say is in good company!
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: mahg33ta on Oct 17, 2010, 09:42 PM
Quotei really like this album.  listened to it on repeat one night & it's just so pleasant sounding.  i seem to quietly sing and hum "questions"  to myself randomly, so i suppose that's my favorite, for now.

re: "different people" - from carl's website (and the liner notes): "written by earl lett (beantown music BMI) additional lyrics by carl broemel"  so, maybe earl lett wrote the ,err, embarassing ones???

http://carlbroemel.com/web/lyrics/

my lithograph info also reads "This is 1 of an Edition of 250" & until i read thru these other posts, i really thought mine was #1 of 250.  when i opened it i thought "geez, i didn't think i was that quick on the draw".  hahaha!

Different People is the only song on the album I dislike.    Probably the only skipper in my MMJ/Carl/MOF collection.   Just bothers me for some reason, AND then goes on a few minutes too long.    But I'll be singin' along Wed night anyway ;)
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: snappythealligator on Oct 18, 2010, 07:07 PM
I find the album to be a quintessential grower, a little dearer with each pass. I talked to Carl for an upcoming interview and the whole thing seemed to come as a happy surprise to him. It feels fresh in that way even without knowing that.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: ralph on Nov 03, 2010, 04:22 AM
i may becoming a little obsessed with this record.  Maybe its because its getting warmer here the mood of this records seems to fit with Spring so well. Very close to being my favorite record this year...
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Crispy on Nov 03, 2010, 09:00 AM
Quotei may becoming a little obsessed with this record.  Maybe its because its getting warmer here the mood of this records seems to fit with Spring so well. Very close to being my favorite record this year...
It's so confusing when you upside-down people talk about Spring coming...  ;)

Such a damn good record.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Nov 03, 2010, 09:25 AM
I've been putting it in the rotation on like every fourth album, can't get enough.  


Carl! Caw!  Carl!  Caw!
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: ralph on Nov 03, 2010, 06:04 PM
I woke up this morning with Questions in my head, but not the album version, but the really awesome live looped version with multiple harmonies and it's now driving me crazy (but in a good way)...
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: ralph on Nov 03, 2010, 06:49 PM
QuoteIt's so confusing when you upside-down people talk about Spring coming...  Wink

from where I sit its you guys that are all backwards! Who has winter in December? Sheesh...
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Nov 23, 2010, 05:21 AM
Did everyone get their Delux version Videos/EPK download?

Watching it now.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: johnnYYac on Nov 23, 2010, 10:54 AM
QuoteDid everyone get their Delux version Videos/EPK download?

Watching it now.
DL'd, not yet watched.  Have we seen most of these already?
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Nov 24, 2010, 05:32 AM
Quote
QuoteDid everyone get their Delux version Videos/EPK download?

Watching it now.
DL'd, not yet watched.  Have we seen most of these already?
Yep. Except for the EPK. It's all really cool though.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: johnnYYac on Nov 24, 2010, 10:32 AM
Just got a .pdf booklet download, too.  Is this approach, with video, additional tracks, and booklet for download, common with other artists' releases these days?
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: ralph on Nov 26, 2010, 05:22 AM
Sitting on the train going home after a few beers after work listening to this record. I'm having overwhelming memories of New York and the week of T5. Of all the music we heard that week, All Birds Say has become my 'New York' record.

It was the best week, and this record will always remind me of that. Lucky that it's a fucken great record!
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: ralph on Nov 26, 2010, 05:43 AM
And can I just add that the 'In your own..., in your own way' line in Sunday Drivers is my single most favorite piece of music released in 2010. Just perfect...
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: tdb810 on Jan 28, 2011, 02:24 PM
Just listening to this again, and reminiscing about the Carl show at Joe's Pub.
What a night, what a great man! He just seems so sweet, and this album is really pretty. 
SNOWY!
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: BH on Jan 28, 2011, 02:27 PM
SNOWY!

SNOWY!

SNOWY!

SNOWY!

SNOWY!

SNOWY!
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: ralph on Jan 28, 2011, 07:36 PM
When MMJ come out for their extended 2011 Australian Tour (!) I hope that Carl plays at least one solo show. Would love to see these songs live again.
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: weeniebeenie on Jan 31, 2011, 05:10 AM
Quote from: ralph on Jan 28, 2011, 07:36 PM
When MMJ come out for their extended 2011 Australian Tour (!) I hope that Carl plays at least one solo show. Would love to see these songs live again.
I would totally be up for something like this. Every time Carl announces a show I get sad that I can't be there. He is so awesome!!
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: johnnYYac on Feb 05, 2011, 12:00 AM
Somebody posted this picture on Carl's Twitter account.  Looks nice.

(http://img.mobypicture.com/d1924f22b75a2775cf7f7eb1f319d412_new_medium.jpg)
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: e_wind on Feb 05, 2011, 12:49 AM
I would love to see a PJ type thing where Carl plays a few solo songs before the opener of every MMJ show
Title: Re: Carl - All Birds Say
Post by: Ruckus on Feb 15, 2011, 09:28 AM
Penny's post about Abigail Washburn's album reminded me about this.  I'm sure it's been posted before but I don't recall it so...here's the EPK

Carl Broemel: "All Birds Say" EPK (http://www.vimeo.com/18925360)