Jacket Bracket Attack 2012

Started by Ruckus, Oct 11, 2012, 02:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

CHIMMJFAN

Quote from: Ruckus on Oct 25, 2012, 12:18 AM
Final First Round Group

Round 1 Group 8:

1. Circuital v. The Way That He Sings
2. New Morning v. Librarian
3. Wordless Chorus v. At Dawn Bonus Track
4. Old September Blues v. Steam Engine
5. Weeks Go By Like Days v. Santa Clause
6. I'm Amazed v. That Someone Else
7. Holy v. It's Been a Great 3 or 4 Years
8. I Will Be There When You Die v. Thank You Too
Ok here we go:
1. Circuital ( tough one!)
2. Librarian
3. At Dawn
4. Steam Engine ( Damn I love Old September Blues, I hate this matchup lol)
5. Weeks Go By Like Days
6. That Someone Else
7. Holy
8. I Will Be There When You Die

Tougher round, losing a lot of good songs I think

CHIMMJFAN
"He got tired of walkin' a tightrope"

cy

1. The Way That He Sings
2. New Morning
3. Wordless Chorus
4. Steam Engine
5. Weeks Go By Like Days
6. I'm Amazed
7. Holy
8. I Will Be There When You Die

Haldon

1. TWTHS
2. Librarian
3. Wordless
4. Steam Engine
5. Santa Claus
6. I'm Amazed
7. Holy
8. IWBTWYD

Fully

The Way That He Sings
Librarian
Wordless Chorus
Old September Blues (This was one of the first Jacket songs I fell in love with. I love Steam Engine, but it's going to win anyway so I'm voting for OSB - which is a fine song)
Weeks Go By Like Days
I'm Amazed
It's Been a Great 3 or 4 Years (Jiiiiiiyyyyyyuuuuuum, Jiiiiiiiyyyyuuuuum - not even a song, but it always makes me laugh when it pops up on shuffle)
I Will Be There When You Die

Crispy


Quote from: Ruckus on Oct 25, 2012, 12:20 AMThe Way That He Sings
New Morning
Wordless Chorus
Steam Engine
Weeks Go By Like Days
I'm Amazed
Holy
I Will Be There When You Die


"Sob it up, make it look real sad and pathetic" - I would like to pick It's Been a Great 3 or 4 Years, I love hearing Jim's favoritest cousin from the McQuaid side of the family. It would have smoked Good Intentions, but it can't beat Holy.
"...it's gonna be great -- I mean me coming back with the band and playing all those hits again"

goldbondking

1. The Way That He Sings
2. Librarian
3. Wordless Chorus
4. Steam Engine
5. Weeks Go By Like Days
6. I'm Amazed
7. Holy
8. I Will Be There When You Die

johnnYYac

1. The Way That He Sings
2. Librarian
3. Wordless Chorus
4. Steam Engine
5. Weeks Go By Like Days
6. I'm Amazed
7. Holy
8. I Will Be There When You Die
The fact that my heart's beating is all the proof you need.

vwxg14a

1. Circuital
2. Librarian
3. Wordless Chorus
4. Steam Engine
5. Weeks Go By Like Days
6. I'm Amazed
7. It's Been a Great 3 or 4 Years - Not a song but I like it.
8. I Will Be There When You Die - Tough one, Really tough

My Morning Jacket - From The Basement - Thank You, Too [live]


Pops, Langerado, Lollapalooza, RCMH, Miami Beach, MSG, St Aug, T5.

weeniebeenie

The Way That He Sings
Librarian
Wordless Chorus
Old September Blues (I know it's blasphemy to vote anything against Steam Engine but I had to!)
Weeks Go By Like Days
I'm Amazed
It's Been a Great 3 or 4 Years (I can never stop laughing when I hear it)
I Will Be There When You Die

How loud can silence get?

e_wind



The Way That He Sings
New Morning
Wordless
Steam
Weeks Go By Like Days
That Someone Else Was You (can't believe I'm Amazd is getting off this easy.
Holy
IWBTWYD
don't rock bottom, just listen just slow down...

mahg33ta

Quote from: cy on Oct 25, 2012, 08:10 AM
1. The Way That He Sings
2. New Morning
3. Wordless Chorus
4. Steam Engine
5. Weeks Go By Like Days
6. I'm Amazed
7. Holy
8. I Will Be There When You Die

these are my votes.   Thanks for continuing to do this Ruckus!

Tutofqueens

The Way That He Sings
New Morning
Wordless
Steam Engine
Weeks Go By Like Days
That Someone Else Was You
Holy
I Will Be There When You Die

tdb810

I feel really old and clueless, but I need clarification. 

At Dawn Bonus Track (is this the Untitled track)? or the Demo?

Holy - is this O Holy Night?


thanks
.....Back at the Model Home

zanjam

1. The Way That He Sings
2. Librarian
3. Wordless Chorus
4. Steam Engine (bye Old Sept, love you!)
5. Weeks Go By Like Days
6. I'm Amazed
7. It's Been a Great 3 or 4 Years (Hilarity!)
8. I Will Be There When You Die
anything + reverb always = better

ItBeats4Jew

The Way That He Sings
Librarian
Wordless
Steam Engine
Weeks Go By Like Days
I'm Amazed
It's Been A Great 3 or 4 Years
I Will Be There When You Die
what Madonna said really helped

Fully

Interesting that brother and sister voted exactly the same. Does Zanjam have It Beats 4 Jew's password.

Crispy

Quote from: tdb810 on Oct 25, 2012, 12:07 PM
I feel really old and clueless, but I need clarification. 

At Dawn Bonus Track (is this the Untitled track)? or the Demo?

Holy - is this O Holy Night?

You're not old, Trish.  :wink:  /ducking


At Dawn Bonus Track is referring to the untitled track at the end of the official At Dawn release. Holy is the next track right after It's Been a Great 3 or 4 Years on Chocolate & Ice!
"...it's gonna be great -- I mean me coming back with the band and playing all those hits again"

tdb810

Quote from: Crispy on Oct 25, 2012, 12:48 PM
Quote from: tdb810 on Oct 25, 2012, 12:07 PM
I feel really old and clueless, but I need clarification. 

At Dawn Bonus Track (is this the Untitled track)? or the Demo?

Holy - is this O Holy Night?

You're not old, Trish.  :wink:  /ducking


At Dawn Bonus Track is referring to the untitled track at the end of the official At Dawn release. Holy is the next track right after It's Been a Great 3 or 4 Years on Chocolate & Ice!
Ok, thanks!  Here goes....

1. The Way That He Sings
2. New Morning
3. Wordless Chorus
4.  Steam Engine
5. Weeks Go By Like Days
6. I'm Amazed
7. Holy
8. I Will Be There When You Die
.....Back at the Model Home

iLikeBeer

1. The Way That He Sings
2. Librarian
3. Wordless Chorus
4. Steam Engine
5. Weeks Go By Like Days
6. I'm Amazed
7. Holy
8. I Will Be There When You Die

Shug

The Way That He Sings
New Morning  (I cannot stand Librarian and I'm baffled that so many people like it)
Wordless Chorus
Steam Engine
I'm Amazed  (I'm not yet burned out on this catchy upbeat song, I love it)
Thank You Too (what a great melody!)

Is New Morning a Dylan cover?  If so all the more reason to vote for it.  the ones that I'm ignorant of, I again abstained from voting.  I need more time discovering these rarities before I can have an informed opinion, but its a great way to be reminded of what I still need to check out, so thanks!
"Some like their water shallow, I like mine deep"