Jacket Bracket Attack Pt. 1: It's Over

[TheBri-Man]

I Will Sing You Songs
Phone Went West
Nashville to Kentucky
Mahgeetah

[mtngurl]

librarian
pww -sorry AMD:(
it beats 4u
mahgeetah

[InTheZone]

I will sing you songs
phone went west
it beats 4 U
mahgeetah

[GoodKid]

I Will Sing You Songs
Phone Went West
It Beats 4 U
Mahgeetah

[pawpaw]

I see you out there db! Waiting to pounce  ;D

[xmascriminal]

Voting is closed on both these matches and round 1.

I Will Sing You Songs: 40
Librarian: 2

Phone Went West: 33
Honest Man: 9

It Beats 4 U: 24
Nashville to Kentucky: 18

Mahgeetah: 35
Evelyn is Not Real: 6

Voting on round 2 begins tomorrow. It'll still be eight days long, but we'll be doing two matches a day instead of four. I'm going to spend the night doing the percentages. If any of you really want to seed the other way, which means that we'd all rank the 32 songs that are left in order of preference, which would be more accurate but a lot more work and time, let me know and your wish will be my command. If not, I'll see you here at 8 PM with round 2. Also, if anybody wants a list of all the songs that are left and/or all the ones we kicked off, that'd be an easy thing to post.

[pawpaw]

Sounds good. Thanks!

[dragonboy]

I see you out there db! Waiting to pounce  ;D

I was gutted yesterday...gutted!!!  ;)

[easy way]

Thanks again xmas...hell of an effort! See you kiddies @ 8.

[BadfooT]

I Will Sing You Songs
Phone Went West
It Beats 4 U
Mahgeetah

[xmascriminal]

I Will Sing You Songs
Phone Went West
It Beats 4 U
Mahgeetah

Too late. You voted for all the winners anyway.

[Grateful Chabo]

percentages sounds good to me....thanks criminal this is badass.  LONG LIVE WAR BEGUN!!

[ycartrob]

while you are waiting...

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Twu7OlFt1c&feature=related[/media]

[xmascriminal]

Really great video. I'd never heard that song live before.

[capt. scotty]

See, based on what some people have posted, it seemed they they thought voting was restricted to *the* studio songs

But it just says that this 1st tourney is songs off their albums, not necessarily studio or live version

I wouldnt change any of my votes, but I just remember some ppl posting how, this studio version gives it the win, or this is so good live it needs to win, but really its not limited to either one

War Begun is a good one, because the live version blows the smoke off the water of the studio version

Also, that whole show for this War Begun (I believe its 6/3/03) is posted on youtube and is flawless quality throughout. Anyone who hasnt seen most/all of that tunage should check you some!!

[Ruckus]

Yes Captain.  I have been voting based on the studio albums as that was my interpretation of the rules.  For sure I would have changed some of my votes if I was to have taken into account the live performances.

Mr. Curtain, perhaps some clarification.  Definitely War Begun, Dondante and Run Thru would have gotten my votes had I contemplated the live performances.  

Heck, I don't even know what I voted for anymore :-?

[xmascriminal]

Yes Captain.  I have been voting based on the studio albums as that was my interpretation of the rules.  For sure I would have changed some of my votes if I was to have taken into account the live performances.

Mr. Curtain, perhaps some clarification.  Definitely War Begun, Dondante and Run Thru would have gotten my votes had I contemplated the live performances.  

Heck, I don't even know what I voted for anymore :-?

I never really specified. I just expected that everybody would mix live and studio together when they thought about a song. I guess that going with the studio recordings might be better since not everyone's seen them live. But personally, I can't help thinking about how great those concerts were and letting that influence me. Round 2 begins in ten minutes.

[aMillionDreams]

I'm still voting on the song with all versions, live and studio, in mind.  Are those not the rules?  Am I over the line?  I guess I'm just a maverick!

[xmascriminal]

Welcome to round 2  :)

I Will Sing You Songs vs. Anytime
Dancefloors vs. Just Because I Do

[xmascriminal]

I vote for Anytime and Dancefloors.