There seems to be a lot of discussion about War on Drugs and Dr Dog, but less about the Band of Horses. I, for one, am a huge fan of BOH and am thrilled they will be joining MMJ this year. I've seen them multiple times, including opening for MMJ at Red Rocks and in Wisconsin with MMJ and Trampled by Turtles. The one critique I had when they played Red Rocks was that they played a pretty similar set both nights. So, I'm really excited that they will be adding an acoustic set this time around. Live at The Ryman has some beautiful songs and hearing Marry song, Funeral, Monsters, No Ones Gonna Love You...etc acoustically will be awesome. If I don't cry a little during Monsters I'd be surprised :wink:
Anyway, it sounds like most folks can't wait for Dr Dog and WOD, but wondering what other thoughts there are on BOH. I am also curious as to what role they may have played in the event selling out, if any.
PS Lets try to bury these threads that take a nasty turn. We are My Morning Jacket fans, not Juggalos.
Good idea, but I'm not going to be nice in my opinion of Band of Bores, Band of Snorlaxes, or MMJ lite. Whatever you want to call them. The best thing about watching their set is that they make MMJ look twenty times better than I already think they are because Band of Bros is so boring. Having said that, I respect your opinion and anyone else's who likes them. I just think that once is enough to see them for a lifetime, and I'm cursed that the band I follow has them open for them more often than not lately.
What Johnny said. I've tried. I'm not a hater, just not a lot to get excited about.
I really like a lot of their music but the live shows have been a bit underwhelming for me. Not bad just not great. I do think the acoustic thing sounds like it might be cool but I may skip the headlining night.
Hoo boy .. this one will definitely get some replies.
I'm a huge fan of Band of Horses, think Ben is brilliant and they're superbly talented. When the MMJ/BOH tour was announced a couple of years ago, I was floored. And yes, I put them at the top of the list in the post-OBH survey for "bands you'd like to see in 2015" (with Alabama Shakes a close second).
But hey, I get it. Not everyone's cup of tea. Same could be said for many bands. You can't rock out to their every song, and if that's your bag, totally understand. I do agree that The Funeral is supremely played out and that's how they're known to many. But there's so much more to BOH ...
So yep, I'm pumped to see them, especially the acoustic sunset show. Has chance to be really cool
Layin low, it looks like there will be plenty of space on the rail for you and I at the BOH shows :thumbsup:
I agree that their last two albums were not as strong as their first two. They are currently recording a new album, and based on the producer they have chosen, it will be more like the first two albums. I hope they debut some new stuff at OBH.
When BOH opens for MMJ there really is no comparison. MMJ is soooo much better in concert. However, I have seen BOH as a headliner and I LOVED this show. It still didn't compare to a MMJ show, but nothing does.
Strong emotions for BOH. I'm torn. While I think their first two albums are outstanding, I am not even the smallest fan of their second two albums. I've seen them open for MMJ and Pearl Jam a few times and their own show once. They're not the most exciting but do have a lot of great songs and sound really good live. Personally, I would prefer something new and different or the War on Drugs to get two slots and BOH one.
Thanks 612 for the intel about the new album and producer. I'm more interested now.
This just makes me more excited to see BoH.
If they were not on the bill, I wouldn't have even purchased tickets for OBH.
I myself am super excited to be seeing Band of Horses. I've seen them a few times, the last being their acoustic tour. I know they will be playing an acoustic set at OBH during sunset.
I've read descriptions of them like Band of snoozes which I personally think is very witty. :rolleyes:
With that being said, the eclectic nature of all the bands playing is a reflection of what My Mornig Jacket seems to be about which is embracing all music.
Quote from: WastedLittleWeeza on Dec 30, 2014, 01:17 PM
This just makes me more excited to see BoH.
If they were not on the bill, I wouldn't have even purchased tickets for OBH.
It's interesting you say this, during the spontaneous creation tour, it seemed the majority of the people at the Milwaukee show were there for BOH. After BOH left the stage, a large portion of the crowd did as well. Worked for me as I got to go up to the third row.. Also when I talked to people, most of them said they were BOH fans. But I definitely wouldn't fork over this kind of money just to see BOH. I do really like them. But regardless of the bands accompanying MMJ at OBH, I would be there.
To each their own, and people can hate all they want. But at the end of the day I really think the haters will wind up enjoying their sets.
Agreed!
I'm just really looking forward to seeing my two favorite bands in Mexico. :beer:
I've tried getting into BoH soley due to the relationship they share with MMJ. I've done so on multiple occaisions, but I still can't seem to jump onboard. For me, the first time I heard and saw WOD and Dr Dog live, I was totally infatuated with their performance - it was unparallel to the BoH show at Forecastle this year. I don't "hate" them, but they're certainly at the bottom of the list with this year's lineup. That being said, if you mix a beach and a live gig, especially with the likely possibility that Jim and the boys could sit in on a few songs - then hell year, I'm there.
I'm a huge Neil Young fan and I read a while ago that Neil likes Band of Horses. He heard them in San Francisco years ago...it's one of the reasons I started listening to them.
Snooze Fest.
Quote from: DaFunkyPrecedent on Jan 09, 2015, 02:25 PM
Snooze Fest.
I'll say it again, Band of Snorlaxes are the band mmj would be if mmj was boring.
Ah...our Jacket...never boring!!!!
Pseudonyms for band names never gets old haha.
Did someone say " Band of Loraxes"[sp]??? :tongue:
Also, there was mention of "My Boring Racket" a long time ago.
Quote from: pattilovesmmj on Jan 10, 2015, 09:28 PM
Ah...our Jacket...never boring!!!!
Ha, seriously. I don't get this really serious hate BOH gets. I mean they're no means my favorite band. however, when I saw them open for Jacket I thought they were a great band. Their energy is lower than MMJ, but how many other bands can bring what the Jacket does. Still they make some good music.
I like them and am really excited to see both sets of theirs. Their Ryman Acoustic show is awesome. Clearly, Jim and the boys see something in them or they wouldn't have toured with them and brought them here. I have a slight suspicion all the people who hate will enjoy the set. I mean, you're on island time, BOH is perfect for relaxation music.
How many people saw them open for MMJ in an outdoor amphitheatre atmosphere vs. a smaller indoor venue? I saw them at one of each and while I felt they didn't really get the larger, spread out outdoor crowd going, I really enjoyed them when I saw them at the Peabody in St. Louis. Their sound just seemed to fill that space better.
And yes, OBH will be outdoor, but will at least be more intimate than an amphitheater I would think. Maybe that's wrong though.
Quote from: justbcuzido on Jan 12, 2015, 11:49 AM
Quote from: pattilovesmmj on Jan 10, 2015, 09:28 PM
Ah...our Jacket...never boring!!!!
Ha, seriously. I don't get this really serious hate BOH gets. I mean they're no means my favorite band. however, when I saw them open for Jacket I thought they were a great band. Their energy is lower than MMJ, but how many other bands can bring what the Jacket does. Still they make some good music.
I like them and am really excited to see both sets of theirs. Their Ryman Acoustic show is awesome. Clearly, Jim and the boys see something in them or they wouldn't have toured with them and brought them here. I have a slight suspicion all the people who hate will enjoy the set. I mean, you're on island time, BOH is perfect for relaxation music.
for sure. i wouldn't be surprised if they don't open for mmi on the supporting tour this year.
Quote from: touchingmept2 on Jan 12, 2015, 10:19 PM
Quote from: justbcuzido on Jan 12, 2015, 11:49 AM
Quote from: pattilovesmmj on Jan 10, 2015, 09:28 PM
Ah...our Jacket...never boring!!!!
Ha, seriously. I don't get this really serious hate BOH gets. I mean they're no means my favorite band. however, when I saw them open for Jacket I thought they were a great band. Their energy is lower than MMJ, but how many other bands can bring what the Jacket does. Still they make some good music.
I like them and am really excited to see both sets of theirs. Their Ryman Acoustic show is awesome. Clearly, Jim and the boys see something in them or they wouldn't have toured with them and brought them here. I have a slight suspicion all the people who hate will enjoy the set. I mean, you're on island time, BOH is perfect for relaxation music.
for sure. i wouldn't be surprised if they don't open for mmi on the supporting tour this year.
Huh? The "for sure" then double negative has me confused. :huh:
Either way I'll throw my hat in the group that's been there, done that, and don't want to do it again as far as BOH opening for Jacket on tour this year.
Haha, re-reading that is confusing :tongue:
I would like to see them tour together is what I meant.
I knew that BoH opened for them a few years back, but I think that it would be a great tour, with a possible lineup that included a newer band to open.
Didn't realize there are so many BOH haters out there! I've seen them quite a bit over the years and they really sound better in a smaller indoor venue. I'll also admit that the last 2 albums aren't nearly as strong as the first 2 stellar albums. I've talked to Ben and Tyler Ramsey a few times after smaller club shows and they are really down to earth and approachable. I think people will be surprised by their acoustic set on the last day of OBH.
Quote from: werduga on Jan 13, 2015, 11:50 PM
Didn't realize there are so many BOH haters out there! I've seen them quite a bit over the years and they really sound better in a smaller indoor venue. I'll also admit that the last 2 albums aren't nearly as strong as the first 2 stellar albums. I've talked to Ben and Tyler Ramsey a few times after smaller club shows and they are really down to earth and approachable. I think people will be surprised by their acoustic set on the last day of OBH.
I saw their acoustic set in Chicago a few months back. It was great!
If I can fall asleep at the new pornographers show but stay awake for BoH, think that says something. lots of peeps think they are snoozy, but listen to their harmonies and acoustic music and I think you'll find they pretty good.
Add me to the group who doesn't get all the hate for this band. Obviously, MMJ doesn't share in the feelings of the haters or they wouldn't continue to invite them on their tours or to join them in Mexico. I guess Neil has no musical sense either since he's on record of liking them as well.
I actually saw them live before I saw my first MMJ show. It was back in 2006 and they were touring with Built To Spill. I was hooked and have seenthem several times at smaller venues since. And when they toured with MMJ, I was very happy to have the opportunity to see two of my favorite bands in one show. I will admit, their last two albums haven't lived up to their first two, but I'm hopeful they will bring it strong on their next release.
I will say, I saw them open for MMJ 3 different dates and 2 of the 3 venues were very sparse crowds so that might have something to do with the apparent lack of energy. But, in Columbus, the venue was PACKED and you could really sense that Ben and the boys were very appreciative and there was definitely a more energized vibe as they were feeding off the crowd and were very appreciative of the support as well.
I think its kind of refreshing that BOH isn't trying to be MMJ light. They clearly don't rock as hard as MMJ so why try to be them. While I haven't loved the last two albums I think the band is really carving out their own niche. I can only commend that.
If you go in to seeing them thinking its basically MMJ that doesn't rock hard you're doing it all wrong. The harmonies are where its at really.
also, Dawes is kind of "Band of Horses light"
I'd be much less excited to see them
Dawes >>>>>>>>> BOH
I've tried a lot with BOH in the past and more recently over the last few months in prep for OBH and I just can't get into them. I don't hat ethem by any stretch but they's something about them that just doesn't agree with my ears. I'll give their live show a shot though for sure.
Every other act on the bill though.... I'm very excited for.
Band of Horses was a nightmare at Forecastle. My group was up close waiting for Jack White, and BOH went on before them. That was the longest 1.5 hours of my life. It's okay, Jack White made up for it!
For the '12 red rocks shows, I made it a point to come later to the second night so I didn't have to suffer through another band of horses set. :) I will do the best I can to enjoy their sets at OBH.
I feel like the BoH debate on this forum is just like the MMJ debate on the Wilco forum. The only difference is that on the Wilco forum we're defending a good band.
Quote from: e_wind on Jan 18, 2015, 09:53 AM
I feel like the BoH debate on this forum is just like the MMJ debate on the Wilco forum. The only difference is that on the Wilco forum we're defending a good band.
Boom, down.
I definitely don't view "Dawes as BOH light". I've seen this almost as many times as I've seen MMJ and they are great live! Everyone in the band is super talented and Taylor and Griffin have great harmonies together. They have a super tight sound and you'll be impressed if you've never seen them live. And what's with all the vitriol for all these awesome bands playing OBH? Go hear something new or go to one of the many bars and get out of the way of the people who want to listen. I can't wait to see ALL the bands!
Quote from: werduga on Jan 18, 2015, 10:18 PM
And what's with all the vitriol for all these awesome bands playing OBH? Go hear something new or go to one of the many bars and get out of the way of the people who want to listen. I can't wait to see ALL the bands!
Thank you! So many people are trying to make this some sort of contest or take digs aka Band of Snooze. We get it. Fact is, MMJ and BOH are good friends, and were invited for a reason. Good thing is there are a lot of other options to do in Riviera Maya while these sets are going on. Or you could just sit back and enjoy the vibe. I wasn't the biggest fan of Flaming Lips so my wife and I took two chairs, sat near the back bars and enjoyed the atmosphere. You're in Mexico for goodness sake!
Really looking forward to the acoustic set!
Hoping the headlining night is a bit more reminiscent of their earlier days...
Quote from: easy way on Jan 25, 2015, 08:11 PM
Really looking forward to the acoustic set!
Hoping the headlining night is a bit more reminiscent of their earlier days...
I'm with you. REALLY excited about the acoustic set. I hope it's not on the main stage. And I'm curious how they'll follow Dr Dog cause I expect the pressure will be on BoH after the Dog set.
FWIW, my co-worker is going and while she likes MMJ, she said she wouldn't be going if not for BOH being on the bill. I can't imagine they will be feeling much pressure during their headlining gig, I feel like they will have a good showing of fans.
I posted earlier in the thread but I think it was kind of overlooked - I saw BOH twice when they opened for MMJ, once at an outdoor venue and once at the Peabody in STL - and I found them MUCH more enjoyable in STL at a more intimate, indoor venue. They just fill the sound there much better. I know OBH isn't indoors, but I would think it at least feels like a more intimate experience than an outdoor pavillion - here's to hoping some of you enjoy!
My main complaint (and I use the word complaint rather lightly) is that BOH is the headliner on the off day. They just don't throw down like a headliner should. Headliner really should have been Dr. Dog or WOD on the off night. But I'm not losing sleep over this. Three nights of MMJ!
Personally, I thought Band Of Horses were great. Admittedly, I'm a big fan of theirs, I caught their pre-show in Orange County two nights before heading down to OBH (BOH were on the same flight as me, talked to them and they were all very cool). Their headlining set was great, and their acoustic set was fun and laid back, although they still had fifteen minutes on the clock when they ended. That bummed me out a bit - would've loved to hear more!
Quote from: sillyboob on Apr 28, 2015, 02:04 PM
Personally, I thought Band Of Horses were great. Admittedly, I'm a big fan of theirs, I caught their pre-show in Orange County two nights before heading down to OBH (BOH were on the same flight as me, talked to them and they were all very cool). Their headlining set was great, and their acoustic set was fun and laid back, although they still had fifteen minutes on the clock when they ended. That bummed me out a bit - would've loved to hear more!
I can really only judge a band after I've seen them live... I first saw Band of Horses live in 2011 opening for MMJ on the Circuital tour and I've loved them ever since. Their live show is high energy and fun and I personally really like their music. Their acoustic set at OBH2 was definitely a highlight for me and my OBH crew. Another reason I've grown to love BoH is because they are all so friendly! My fiancee and I stopped Ben at OBH and he talked to us about random shit for 20 minutes! I just really like the band's overall attitude and I think they are a perfect addition to anything MMJ wants to touch. Plus it really seems like both the MMJ and BoH fellas are good friends, so that is great reason for them to keep playing together. Personally, I'd be happy if they were back at OBH3. And please please please bring Dr. Dog back too!